Stitch Fix #1 – What I Got & What I Kept

Stitch Fix review with a beautiful statement necklace and a sleeveless teal top! Love it!Well, who’s excited??

I am!

I received my first Stitch Fix a few weeks ago, and have been so excited to share it all with you! If you don’t know what Stitch Fix is, let me quickly explain:

You tell a stylist what you like in clothes and accessories. That stylist picks out 5 items they think you would like (or maybe push you out of your comfort zone a little) and sends you a box. You try on the clothes, at home, with your existing wardrobe. Keep and pay for what you want, return what you don’t.

I didn’t expect an 100% winning box right out the gate, but most of the items were really great! I did, however, return all but 1 item. But I’m not disappointed!

Let’s just get right down to the items, shall we? I’ve got prices, close up shots and outfit pictures of each piece.

1. Fun2Fun Sheridan Striped V-Neck Tab Sleeve Blouse – $48 – RETURNED

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

I know why I got sent this shirt. I mentioned I love stripes and loose shirts with details. So this fit the bill! I really liked the shoulder detail on this shirt, and you can never go wrong with stripes! But this shirt was a bit too slouchy for me, and the arms looks baggy too. So, I returned it. (And look! Blurry picture! Camera must have decided to focus on something else instead…)

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

2. Loveappella Devon Pleated Mini Skirt – $38 – RETURNED

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

This was a really easy skirt – stretchy, comfortable, and navy! But, at the end of the day, it was a tad too short and lightweight (could see a little gust of wind blowing it up) and bubbled out at my tushy. But I love that pleated detail in the front! It really is adorable. If it was a tad longer (it hit me above the knee), I would have kept it!

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

3. Mavi Zoola Denim Top – $74 – RETURNED

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

There were a few things wrong with this top. First, is $74 for a denim shirt with snaps…. I have a similar one hanging in my closet from Target, complete with snaps. Second, as already stated, I have more than my share of chambray/denim tops. Not Stitch Fix’s fault, but still, didn’t need another one. And third, it just didn’t fit well. It just didn’t snap over the twins and the hips. But I did like the fading!

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

4. Collective Concepts Esten Button-Up Sleeveless Blouse – $54 – KEPT IT!
Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

Yay! A winner! This ticked so many wonderful boxes. It was lightweight and loose, but not too loose. I love the color of this! Not to mention the fact that it’s not so sheer that I have to wear a cami under it (that gets old in the summer time). And love that the v-neck isn’t too deep. Since I didn’t have a shirt in that color, I thought it was a keeper. The perfect shirt for dressing up or down!

Stitch Fix #1 Review from Cup of Tea Blog

5. Romolo Monet Mini Facet Bib Necklace – $38 – RETURNED


This necklace was a surprise! It’s so pretty – I love the colors in it. And the shape is different – love a bib necklace! But, I returned it because I have a necklace pretty darn similar to it, so figured I didn’t really need it… But isn’t it pretty with that teal top?

So that’s it! Stitch Fix #1 in the bag! I’m not ready to do a full review of it just yet, because it’s not fair to judge something on the first try, but so far, pretty happy! For my next box, I asked to see more skirts, preferably longer and maybe even patterned. We shall see!

If you want to learn more about getting your own Fix, you can check it out here. FYI – that link is a referral link/code, so that if you choose to sign up, I get a credit.

What do you think? What would you have kept? Think I made the right decision?

Follow me: Instagram | YouTube | TwitterFacebook | Google+ | BlogLovin’ | Pinterest



  1. Miljoy says:

    The blouse is such a win on you! Looks just lovely with your complexion. Good for you being particular about what you chose to keep. I think I’d be tempted to keep it all since I haven’t gone shopping in ages!

    • Katie @ Cup of Tea says:

      Thank you! And it was tempting, because most of the pieces I liked! There was just something a little wrong… But I agree – I love that color!

  2. Whitney says:

    You look lovely in these colors! I agree with your keeps – you definitely picked the items that seemed like you. I love the variety and I’ve heard that the more specific your feedback, the better your next fix is. I’d love to give it a try one day 🙂

  3. Laura says:

    This is a great idea! You would look great in anything, though, I’m sure!!
    Can you please come and dress me? I can’t get out of my yoga pants!

  4. Erin says:

    I love Stutch Fix. I think I’m on my 8th one. I generally only keep 1-2 items, but I still love it.

    Your face in the denim shirt is too funny! The teal blouse you kept is a really flattering color for you!

Leave a Reply